Value-Stock-Plus

Informed Investing!

Investing is most intelligent when it is most businesslike - Benjamin Graham (1894-1976)

____________________________________________________________________

Value-Stock-Plus stands at No. 50 in the list of Top 100 Finance Blogs  by ValueWiki

Recognised by The Economic Times as one of the most popular financial blog

Updated! Compilation on Warren Buffett, Rakesh Jhunjhunwala & Charlie Munger
____________________________________________________________________

Thursday, September 28, 2006

Unitech’s unreal rise

The share price of Unitech Ltd has gained 66.7% since September 1, 2006. The stock has been hitting the upper circuit for the last three days and closed at Rs 320.45 on September 27. The reasons can be partly traced to last week’s management presentation to investors disclosing details of various projects and their implementation schedule. The surprise element came in the form of the geographical split of its land bank, which - contrary to general belief - is well-spread across all regions and not restricted to the National Capital Region. The company also disclosed plans for its four multi-product and sector-specific special economic zones (SEZ). These revelations seem to have excited the market. CLSA has come out with a positive report and has estimated the net present value (NPV) of Unitech at Rs 429 per share - on the basis of 397 million square feet (MSF) of constructed saleable space, 65.7 MSF to be sold as plots (excluding SEZs) and a weighted average selling price of Rs 3,350 per sq ft.

But the market is obviously not differentiating between plans and their execution. Given growing protests over SEZs, the need for environmental clearance and permission for conversion of agriculture land to non-agriculture use, real estate investment experts do not rule out delays. CLSA estimates that every six months of average delay will change the NPV by Rs 35 per share.

Secondly, any significant increase in interest rates can also dampen demand for homes, which is a large contributor to Unitech’s revenues. Lastly, if real estate prices cool off from their current high levels, it will lead to lower profits for the real estate division, which accounted for 54.6% of total segmental profits in 2005-06. As per CLSA estimates, a 1% change in selling prices will lead to a 2% change in NPV per share. Rising real estate prices (during the last two years) have helped consolidated profit margins for the real estate division jump from 7.7% in 2003-04 to 22% in 2005-06. The construction division’s margins rose from 8.5% to 13% during this period.

Unitech’s plans, which involve completing most of its projects (excluding SEZs) by 2013, translate to construction of an average 66 MSF annually for the next seven years. Contrast this with the fact that the company has developed just over 10 MSF and about 1,000 acres in plots during the last 20 years. Also, compare this with 28 MSF of constructed area (residential, commercial and retail) delivered in Mumbai (including Thane and New Mumbai) and 20 MSF in Pune during 2005-06. Are the markets listening?

Source: DNA Money

Capital goods: Look before you leap!

Growth in user industries like power, construction, refining, textiles, automobiles, and other manufacturing, has led to strong performance by the Indian capital goods and heavy industries companies in the past 2-3 years. Apart from creating sufficient domestic supplies, the growth in capacity expansion and improvement in productivity levels has also led to these companies charting a more confident global route than ever before. In fact, as per the Engineering Exports Promotion Council of India, India's heavy industrial and capital goods exports, which have grown at a compounded rate of 32% during the period FY01 to FY05, are estimated to grow at a rate of 25% per annum during the period FY04 to FY09.

However, do these statistics and growth prospects definitely mean that investors should be blindfolded in their approach to investing in stocks from the sector? Not really!

While we have a positive view on the sector in terms of improving revenue visibility on the back of burgeoning order books of players across the sector, which is a consequence of the huge investment plans from public and private sector enterprises, there are a host of risks that surround these companies' prospects.

Over the past few years, considering the huge opportunity that the sector brings along, there has been a multi-layer increase in the number of participants in the capital goods and heavy engineering sector - multi-layer because the increase has been seen across the spectrum pf projects and heavy equipment segments. This has led to an increase in 'commoditisation' of the industry, whereby companies are fighting for volumes by sacrificing profitability. Even the best and most diverse of the companies have not been able to perk up their margins significantly in the past two years. While higher input prices are definitely a reason for lacklustre margin profile of many of these companies, there is no denying the fact that commoditisation has taken a serious toll across sub-segments, be it infrastructure creation, or power.

Another negative offshoot of the business opportunity has been increasing challenges for companies on the employee acquisition and retention front. Some of the companies have even indicated of attrition levels of 10% to 15%, which, unless clarified, might seem like employee churn in the IT services and BPO industry. Some critical divisions of these companies, like design and project execution, are in fact facing the biggest crunch in terms of talent acquisition and retention. And, apart from rise in employee costs, this has led to a big part of the crucial management time getting diverted to human resource issues.

Finally, as a flip side to the 'high visibility' factor in terms of burgeoning order books, there emerge equally high levels of high execution risks. This is because companies from the sector are increasingly adding contracts that have long gestation periods, or long execution cycles. Among many, this leads to risks from changes in business climate and uncertain movement of commodity prices.

And, what about valuations? Well, this is one of the foremost concerns that we have with the capital goods/heavy engineering stocks. With some of the leading companies trading at price to earnings multiple of as high as 40 times trailing twelve months' earnings, despite factoring in all kinds of positives like visibility and improved execution capabilities, we are uncomfortable with respect to the overall sector valuations.

As indicated above, apart from the 'visibility' part (as seen from big order bookings), investors need to clearly understand the risks associated with the same. While the need to sustain high levels of growth through creation of world-class infrastructure facilities shall continue to provide companies from the sector with multiple growth options, you, as an investor, need to identify whether the price that needs to be paid for the ensuing growth is justifiable or not.

Source: EM

Additional Readings:
  • Ethanol: A global perspective
  • Software companies: Sensitive to the currency!
  • Penny scrips lose way on Street
  • Low buying conviction in evidence
  • Bankex hits new high on better treasury show
  • Promoters up stake in RIL by 2 pc
  • What constitutes a wrong investment?
  • End sops, allow free trade: Manmohan
  • Easing out retail investors will be a setback
  • Are valuations for banking stocks still attractive?
  • Is this a broad-based rally? Will it fizzle out?
  • Brokers bullish on Orient Paper, Ranbaxy, IVRCL
Off-Topic Readings:
  • Singapore bans Far Eastern Economic Review magazine
  • Economists downgrade rating agencies
  • Too many FM stations spoil the party?
  • How to invest in stocks with NO risk
Parting Thought:
  • John Maynard Keynes essentially said, don't try and figure out what the market is doing. Figure out a business you understand, and concentrate. - Warren Buffett

Posted by toughiee at 9:55 PM | Permalink | Comments | links to this post

A Note

Hi All Value-Stock-Plus blog visitors, I hope you enjoy all articles, links & research reports which have posted. I would like to clarify one thing on posting of articles -- I am NOT a writer & have NOT wrote any articles on this blog. I usually get interesting articles from other websites and post it here. There are many sources for the same like Equitymaster.com (EM), Business World India (BWI), Business-Standard (BS), etc.

Please note that wherever possible I mention the original name of author or the website in the post!

The main purpose of this blog is to get all daily interesting information on one page so that people do not have to visit 15-20 sites daily just to read different articles. I have got many feedback from visitors on this issue & they seem happy for the same.

I hope I have made my position very clear on this issue.
Regards, Toughiee
Blog Founder & Editor

Posted by toughiee at 9:05 PM | Permalink | Comments | links to this post

Wednesday, September 27, 2006

A thing or two about midcaps...

"Growth means change and change involves risk, stepping from the known to the unknown." - Anonymous

Perhaps, this quote perfectly symbolizes investments into mid-cap stocks. These involve risks - stepping from the known (large caps, for which information is widely available) to the unknown (mid-caps, where information availability is low). While much has been talked about mid-cap stocks and the upside potential, lets understand what mid-caps actually mean and how should one go about investing in such stocks for the long-term?

Midcap or Mid-tier stocks? Market cap (or market capitalisation), put simply, is the product of the stock price and the number of stock shares issued. As such, a Company X with issued shares of 100 m and stock price of Rs 30 will have market cap of Rs 3,000 m (US$ 65 m). There are two factors here:

  1. Share capital: The quantum of share capital varies sector-to-sector i.e. a smaller bank is likely to have a significantly larger capital base than a smaller company from the software sector because banks, by nature, need capital to grow. Take the example here. ING Vysya Bank's market capitalisation is Rs 5,999 (based on the market price on June 14th 2006) whereas the market capitalisation of Mangalam Cement is Rs 3,433 m (US$ 76 m). To put things in perspective, Mangalam Cement's turnover is Rs 3,090 m whereas the income from operations for ING Vysya Bank in FY06 was Rs 12,224 m. The nature of the business therefore, has a significant influence on the market capitalisation.

  2. Stock price: Perhaps this is the most misunderstood part of the whole midcap hype. Stock markets are hardly 'perfect' and the current stock price of a company may or may not reflect the long-term value and therefore, the market capitalisation may be depressed. Secondly, there is a general perception that a stock trading at Rs 32 is a midcap (Ashok Leyland) as compared to a stock trading at Rs 730 (Tata Motors). What is important to focus in the case of midcap are 'valuations' and not the 'stock price'.

Given this backdrop, what actually is a midcap? Actually, there are no industry standards with respect to the classification of a midcaps per se. Given the NSE's categorization of mid-cap stocks (representing companies with market cap between Rs 750 m and Rs 7,500 m), ING Vysya is not a midcap stock, which in our view, is not true. So, it is in this context that investors should focus on the size of sector and the size of the company in the sector. This, one should compare with the largest in the sector to arrive at a conclusion. This is important because the size of some sectors is very small on a relative basis (like ceramics and paper). For instance, a company like Ballarpur Industries may be among the largest in the paper sector, but when compared with other sectors, it is a mid-tier company. Do not go by hearsay. Some basic level of research will reveal whether a company is really a midcap or not.

How do these differ from large & small caps? The answer to this question lies in understanding what is a large-cap! Take the case of a company like Gujarat Ambuja Cements. A company with a 20 year operating track record, professionally managed, regionally diversified cement manufacturing plants, revenues of over US$ 700 m and one of the most cost competitive producer of cement in the world. Compare this with Chettinad Cement - less than 1% of industry capacity, a regional player, revenues of just over US$ 100 m, just over 500 employees and yet to learn that size is important (capacity at 1.5 MT has been stagnant over the last five years). The table below compares three cement companies, which puts things in perspective.

Large Vs Mid Vs Small…
ParameterGujarat AmbujaChettinad CementMangalam Cement
Capacity (MT)13.3 1.5 1.0
Revenues (Rs m)30,855 3,865 3,029
EBDITA per tonne (Rs)641 419 235
Profit after tax per tonne (Rs)407 126 114
Market Capitalisation (Rs m)157,669 10,435 5,777

Mid cap stocks are generally more risky than large cap stocks and less risky than small caps. It has been seen in the past that risk of failure decreases as companies grow in size. As they grow large, they enjoy better bargaining power with suppliers and customers (except companies in a regulated industry like power and fertilisers) and have stronger systems in place with respect to tackling competitive forces. On the contrary, as companies grow large in size, their growth gets saturated (due to a high base effect), thus under performing the much smaller mid-size companies, which have room to grow into large ones. As such, when considering an investment in a mid cap stock, you need to decide if the stock in question has the potential to grow into a larger company. If you are right in your analysis and follow your action of investing into the stock, you will have a successful investment.

When one invests in mid-caps for the long-term, he is participating in companies that will become blockbusters of tomorrow. A few years back, during the initial phase of the post-liberalisation period, there were a very few large cap companies listed on the Indian bourses. Currently, one would find more than 70 with US$ 1 bn and above in market cap (see adjacent chart). It is pertinent to note that the likes of Infosys were once a mid-tier company.

How to select good mid-caps? Unlike large caps, where there is no dearth of information, for mid-cap stocks, investors need to put in greater energies while doing their homework for identifying good long-term investment prospects - companies that will become much larger because of better opportunities, strong progress and robust growth.

As such, we outline some key guiding factors for selection of good companies from the mid-cap space.

  1. Management: Unlike many of the larger companies, perhaps one of the major risks is that many of the smaller companies, barring exceptions, are family managed. Before investing, it is pertinent to understand the promoter group as a whole. The other things that we as a research house focus on is on the last five to ten year track record of the company, key accounting policies over the years, private placements of shares and how deep is the top-tier management.

  2. Identify the leaders - Current and potential: Investors would do well to identify mid-cap companies that are leaders in their respective business operations. These companies are generally the larger ones from the mid-cap space and have better abilities to tide over volatilities that impact mid-size companies like them. When growth happens, these companies are much better equipped to consolidate their position and grow larger in size.

  3. Identify niche and focused businesses: This is a very important consideration while researching mid-cap stocks. Operations in a niche space (like PLM for Geometric Software) help companies to shelve themselves from competition while providing differentiation benefits to customers. There are niche companies in commodity sectors as well (like iron ore manufacturers, cement manufacturers with a strong regional presence, focused manufacturers in textiles, FMCG companies with strong brands, MNC companies with a strong parent support). At the end of the day, the concerned company should have capabilities to tide over business cycles.

  4. Liquidity: As we have seen in the past stock market cycles, it is important that a investor is aware of the liquidity situation i.e. what is the free-float (non-promoter holding), the last one year average volume and the last one-year average value of shares traded. The traded value is important because at times, the share price can give a distorted picture of the liquidity situation (in fact, many institutional investors focus more on value traded than volumes traded).

Last but not the least, have a cap for your midcap exposure, no matter how adventurous you are! By cap, we mean, as a percentage of the overall portfolio, midcap should not be more than 30% to 50%. This discipline is very critical for investors in general. Ultimately, Rome was not built in a day!

Source: EM

Additional Readings:
  • Bullish on emerging markets: IFC
  • How does Merrill Lynch view emerging markets?
  • 'Do not sell' theme prevailing in markets: Rajesh Jain
  • India tops the BRICS pack
  • Hedge funds put big money on rate calls
  • Brokers bullish on Bharat Elect, Asian Paints, Subex Azure
Off-Topic Readings:
  • Harvard Review to print from Mumbai soon
  • It's survival of the fittest, Lord Paul tells India Inc
Parting Thought:
  • I've often felt there might be more to be gained by studying business failures than business successes. - Warren Buffett

Posted by toughiee at 5:55 PM | Permalink | Comments | links to this post

Tuesday, September 26, 2006

Markets: To do or not to do?

The last three months have brought cheers to the stock markets, after the correction witnessed towards the end of May and in June. In fact, the correction opened doors of opportunity to invest in stocks at reasonable valuations, which was hitherto not the case from the start of the year till mid May. However, the journey to the 12,000+ mark has been an arduous one. And now that this mark has been breached, it is time once again for investors to reflect on certain points before investing in a particular stock.

India Story - A reality check is important: While buying opportunities at these levels have diminished to a certain extent, it is all the more imperative that investors become choosy while putting their money in a stock. Yes, the Indian growth story is a reality. But the GDP growth may not sustain at the current level, considering that there is no major initiatives to solve the great infrastructure hurdle the country is faced with today. Like every other government, the ruling party also talks about the need to grow at over 10%. But since it came into the power, the government is grappling with mundane issues like disinvestments while the actual need is to boost investment.

Financial strength - Look deep inside: At the end of the day, it all boils down to numbers. Whether the company has been consistently delivering good performances year over year can be gauged by its revenue growth and profitability and more importantly its return ratios. Other important criteria would be the extent to which the company is leveraged (a highly leveraged company will see its profitability getting hurt in a rising interest rate scenario) and its history of dividend payouts. In the last three years, the debt to equity ratios of the corporate sector has improved not only because of the restructuring but also due to the fact that many have raised money through equity issues, which has resulted in lowering the debt to equity ratio (needless to say it is not the case with the NSE 50 companies). In our view, over the next two years, the broader return ratios will dent a bit (because these companies are in a expansion phase). We do not see significant upside potential to return ratios from the current level (individual brilliance of course, can exist).

Management depth - Bite what you can chew! The management's vision in anticipating changes in the sector and steering the growth of the company according plays an important role. Also, as we have mentioned in the earlier point about the importance of strong financials, the same also reflect the management's ability to capitalise on growth opportunities and come out stronger in times of adversities. Every other company we meet these days have ambitious growth plans. When asked whether they have the internal resources to execute their business plan in a timely manner, every company is finding it difficult to retain/attract quality manpower. We have serious apprehensions about many mid-tier companies' growth aspirations over the long-term.

Valuations: While the growth prospects of a company may look good, valuations also have to justify the same. Currently, the Sensex is trading at a price-to-earnings (P/E) multiple of around 20.8 times its trailing 12-months' earnings, which is by no means cheap. Irrespective of whether it is a large-cap or a mid-cap, valuations based on one-year forward earnings estimates are expensive in most cases. But on a relative basis, we find many attractive companies in the midcap space with a two to three year investment horizon. We suggest investors not to get carried away by fancy valuation parameters like PEG (price to growth), EV/Sales (enterprise value by sales) and market capitalisation to order book. It is a bull market and market intermediaries will a stock a 'Buy' when it is actually a 'Sell' using fancy names.

To sum up... At these levels, it is time for investors to do some serious thinking.

  1. Why am I investing in equities? If it is short-term gains (stay away!). If it is aimed at meeting one's long-term financial goals (then, allocate your assets according to your risk profile). Remember, equities is 'one' of the asset classes and not 'the' answer to all your financial aspirations.

  2. Why should I focus on the short-term when I can buy a good story for the long-term and not worry about day-to-day price fluctuations?

  3. Do I have the time and the skill-set to monitor my portfolio periodically or should I give my money to a good fund manager?

We cannot answer these questions for you because the risk-return profile of each individual can be different. To sum up, it is time for introspection!

Additional Readings:
  • Hitting a BRIC Wall? by Morgan Stanley - MUST READ!
  • Archies: Disappointing quarter
  • If I can leap into the market, so can you
  • The best & worst IPO performers of 2006-07
  • Wait for Q2 results before buying into tech stocks: Baliga
  • UBS gives a buy call on Tata Steel
  • How does Merrill Lynch view emerging markets?
  • How to avoid 'wrong' investments
  • How Sebi norms will affect FIIs
  • Some good midcap stocks to buy
  • Brokers bullish on ONGC, WS Industries, MphasiS, PVR
Off-Topic Readings:
  • Google on the prowl for takeovers
Parting Thought:
  • Money, to some extent, sometimes lets you be in more interesting environments. But it can't change how many people love you or how healthy you are. - Warren Buffett

Posted by toughiee at 7:04 PM | Permalink | Comments | links to this post

Monday, September 25, 2006

Joyless 12,000

by Dhirendra Kumar I remember once reading in a magazine article how India's cricket victories seemed to put the whole country in a better mood. For a day or two after a cricketing triumph, people are a little more polite and easy-going, they are a more sociable, they quarrel less easily, police constables hit rickshaw-pullers with less vigour and so on. And of course, the opposite happens when India loses.
I guess it's only to be expected that the movements of the BSE Sensex produce a similar cycle of mood swings among investors and others who are involved with the stock markets. Why, there are news anchors on some TV channels who narrate each fall of the Sensex as if it were a personal tragedy for them. But then, what do I know, it may actually be a personal tragedy for some of them.
However, something seems to be have been broken in this Sensex-mood linkage currently. The Sensex is back above 12,000 and yet I see none of those broad smiles and shining eyes among stock market types. Even Sensex headlines printed on pink newsprint don't have those ghastly puns anymore. This is a joyless 12,000. It's as if the cricket team has won, but the opponents were Namibia or Nepal.
The reason why this is so is very simple--this 12,000 is an illusion. The personal Sensex of most investors is depressingly far from having reached 12,000. When the Sensex was initially heading across these levels, it was carrying along as camp followers a huge majority of the stocks traded on the markets. When the Sensex fell, they all fell, and the more speculative mid-caps and small-caps fell far more than the Sensex.
While this was expected--smaller companies generally rise or fall more than larger companies in any broad market movement, there was a human problem behind the statistics. There was a large population of inexperienced investors who had been attracted to the markets during the last three months of the bull-run. Somehow, when stocks start rising indiscriminately, it's always the newbie who has blundered in looking for easy money who gets to buy the duds. But that actually confuses the cause and the effect. What really happens is this: Since only the easily-fooled and inexperienced momentum-chaser puts money into the dud stocks, the rise of the duds is a sure sign of foolish money flowing into the markets.
Here's the full story. First the wise money goes into the good stocks and makes them rise. Then, using the ruboff from this, the clever money goes into dud stocks and nudges them up. Then, the foolish money goes into the duds, replacing the clever money (which sells out). Then the markets fall and the foolish money and its owners part company. And then the cycle starts all over again.
Normally, the cycles are so far apart that by the time one comes around, the foolish money has forgotten the previous one. This time, it's different. The break in the cycle was just a brief interruption and the foolish money is still around licking its wounds, with very fresh memory of what happened the last time. And that should make the next few months very interesting.
Additional Readings:
  • Participatory Notes to stay for now
  • Oil Prices Drop Below $60 a Barrel
  • Participation remains on the fence: Amit Dalal
  • Go stock-by-stock in smallcap & midcap: DSP ML
  • Inflation can be reined by current rates: FM
  • Brokers bullish on RIL, Omax Auto, Ipca Labs
  • Bull run bypasses penny stocks this time
  • Hints of swings, but which way will it be?
  • Emerging currencies slip on risk aversion
  • Crude oil: Basic facts
  • Power: What India wants?
  • Flashy's out, sober's in - Roe Hungry Entrepreneurs’ is how a recent research report by a leading global brokerage firm chooses to describe Indian company managements. India Inc’s fixation on return on equity (RoE), a profitability measure, is legendary and is among the major reasons for a relentless bull run.
  • Patient plays - At these levels, retail investors have to be very selective with their stock picks. Also, they must have the patience to allow their investments to work for them.
  • Sidekicks take centrestage - Providers of oil-related services are in a sweet spot, as they feed off the booming oil companies.
The Amaranth Effect
  • Amaranth blow-out
  • Houses, Hedge Funds -- No Place to Hide From Risk: Chet Currier
  • One Hedge Fund's Wilting Fortunes
  • Amaranth: the letter to investors
  • Mere Mortals, and 100,000 Positions in a Single Futures Contract
Additional Reports:
  • The New Market Leaders - BS
Off-Topic Readings:
  • I am not against SEZs: Chidambaram
  • Management gems from Dhirubhai
  • The great Indian SEZ rush
  • 6 cr loss per day for India's airlines - Another reason to avoid aviation sector!
  • Own too many stocks? Here's help
Parting Thought:
  • I don't try to jump over 7-foot bars. I look around for 1-foot bars that I can step over. - Warren Buffett

Posted by toughiee at 6:54 PM | Permalink | Comments | links to this post

The New Market Leaders

by SI Team Infosys has regained its top slot in terms of market-cap in the technology space. The pecking order of mid-cap companies has changed dramatically compared to the May peak. Reliance continues to be the top traded stock, though the trading interest is down compared to the May peak. The new markets have seen substantial change in trading interest across stocks.
  • Click here to download Chart Book 2006 MUST MUST READ!! (pdf file - 1.5 mb)

Posted by toughiee at 6:34 PM | Permalink | Comments | links to this post

Saturday, September 23, 2006

Sensex on the brink?

The theory of reversion to the mean suggests that the Bombay Stock Exchange Sensex should see some kind of correction soon. According to the hypothesis, the more the moving average of the Sensex shifts away from the index’s closing value as on that date, the sharper will be its drop.
We took Sensex data for the past five years and plotted the difference between the 50-day moving average and the index itself. The chart indicates that this difference was at its highest, at approximately 1,250 points, when the Sensex peaked on May 10, 2006. The decline was steep from there, with 3,683 points getting shaved off the index in just 25 trading sessions.
In the last five years, there hasn’t been such a large gap between the moving average of the index and its closing value. Which brings us to more recent weeks. Since mid-August 2006, there have been four days when the difference has been over 1,000 points, including last Thursday, when it was 1,005 points. Technical analysts are a tad worried, because if one discounts May, 2006, the difference has never been so large.
Recent data also indicate that foreign institutional investors (FIIs) have been buying in the cash market and selling futures. In September, they have been net buyers by Rs 3,691 crore in the former and net sellers by Rs 3,413 crore in the latter. But analysts say that this cash market buying could be a temporary phenomenon, since they seem to be using these stockmarket operations to short the dollar against the rupee by proxy in the belief that the rupee will strengthen. If this latter trend reverses, the FIIs could change tack as well.
Source: DNA Money
Additional Readings:
  • Consolidation likely as markets at 4-month high
  • SEZ Rush: 267 and Counting... - Morgan Stanley
  • Debating the Growth Sustainability of China and India - Morgan Stanley
  • The End of the Great Bond Bull Market - Morgan Stanley
  • India is the world's fastest wealth creator
  • Can Bajaj overtake Hero Honda in 2007?
  • Money in any form is money, honey!
  • Are you an investor or trader?
  • Amaranth effect on Indian firms
  • It's easiest to stick to frontliners: Rajesh Jain
  • The Amaranth effect: Sterling Biotech plunges 12%
  • Slowdown in US economy won't affect India much: DSP ML
Off-Topic Readings:
  • All you want to know about smart homes
  • Petrol prices may drop: Deora
Parting Thought:
  • I wouldn't mind going to jail if I had three cellmates who played bridge. - Warren Buffett

Posted by toughiee at 7:30 PM | Permalink | Comments | links to this post

Friday, September 22, 2006

The Difference Between Speculation and Gambling

Four good reasons why the stock market is not a gambling den...by Deena Mehta

In India, stock markets are often associated with gambling. In many cities, the lane where the futures markets—stocks and commodities—are located is called satta bazaar , and those associated with it are labelled as gamblers. So it's not surprising that in a country of nearly 100-crore population, slightly more than 2 million people participate in secondary markets and about 30 million hold shares. Even today, many belonging to the older generation usually offer cautionary words of advice to those in the younger generation who are keen to dabble in stocks and shares.

But is this cautionary advice justified? Before answering the question, let us understand the difference between gambling and speculation.

Some of the popular avenues for gambling are betting on cricket, football or horse racing, on the outcome of an event (such as a lottery, casino games), or a simple toss of a coin. These events, by themselves, do not carry a risk element. For example, cricket is a sport that will be enjoyed irrespective of who wins. At best, if the home team loses, the crowd may get disappointed. A spectator will not lose money, merely watching the game. But if he bets on the result of the game by wagering his money, a risk element gets created. So, there is no risk per se with the event, but betting imputes the risk.

Given below are some typical apprehensions that people have about share investments and my view on why they are thinking wrong .

Apprehension No. 1: RISK

When we have cash, there is always risk—of devaluation due to inflation if we keep the cash idle, of it being stolen or spent by near and dear ones, of investing in low-return options (which we term `loss of opportunity'). Hence, by investing the cash, we are trying to minimise the risk already present and get a higher return by identifying better-income avenues. There is no creation of risk.

Apprehension No. 2: VOLATILITY

The volatility in the markets is also a reason cited for regarding shares as an unreliable form of investment. People point out that markets fluctuate every day, and their ignorance of the market-movement and fear of loss of capital holds them back. But volatility should be looked upon as an opportunity. If the market is not volatile, there would be no opportunity to make money. When the market goes up, it presents the opportunity to sell, and when it comes down, the opportunity to buy.

Apprehension No. 3: LOSS

Investors have another favourite argument: I buy high and sell low and lose money all the time. In order to make money on the market, there has to be a long-term engagement with the stock markets. Typically, people who say that they bought high and sold low are those who enter the market at the peak of a bull run because they feel left out when the momentum is building up. Soon after the market takes a dip (or a plunge), they are left with high-priced stocks. Their patience runs out and they dispose of their scrips at whatever price they get and take sanyas from share investment. Moral: It is necessary to be constantly in touch with the markets to understand their ups and downs and ride the wave to make money.

Apprehension No. 4: UNPREDICTABILITY

Disillusioned investors like to say the markets are unpredictable because of operator activity and price rigging, a characteristic of gambling. But they should understand that there are going to be undesirable elements in every market. We have to define our area of operation and guard ourselves against such risks. This can be done by restricting our activity to A and B1 group stocks only. These are highly liquid stocks and not prone to manipulation. Low capital and T2T category items have a higher probability of price increase, along with the appended risk of them being prone to price manipulation. These shares have a low capital base; hence, it takes very little cash to rig the prices in the desired direction. After every bull run, investors are stranded with stocks that have no liquidity, company addresses that are untraceable and other allied reasons that render the share worthless. This happens because stocks are not bought on merit but on rumours of operator activity. By defining exit levels (in terms of desired returns) and stop loss levels, an investor can guard against steep capital depreciation.

To conclude, financial planning is a must for every family. It involves building up a portfolio of investments in various instruments that not only meet your needs of cash liquidity but also acts as an earning partner. We mistakenly assume that we are the sole earning members of the family while ignoring the contribution that wise investments can make in sharing the load. A little time devoted to financial planning can reduce the burden multifold. Understanding the suitability of each avenue in the right perspective can go a long way in enhancing the returns on your portfolio.

Source: BW

Posted by toughiee at 10:09 PM | Permalink | Comments | links to this post

Markets and economy: The stumbling blocks!

'India is not on autopilot to greatness. But it would take an incompetent pilot to crash the plane'. These words of Mr. Edward Luce very aptly define the contours of the Indian economy. The economy has been growing at an average annual growth rate of nearly 6% since the 1980s, and at over 8% during the last three years. Besides, India has also shown considerable resilience during the recent years and avoided adverse contagion impact of several shocks. This has precipitated to increased confidence in the country's financial markets with a consistent increase in gross domestic investment rate from 23% of GDP in FY02 to 30% in FY06. The gross domestic saving rate has also improved from 24% to 29% over the same period, contributed by a significant turn around in public sector saving. A case in this point is that the inflows into mutual funds alone have multiplied 10 times in the last decade and is currently at all time highs!

For this buoyancy to sustain, the country will have to tide over several stumbling blocks.

Inherent flaws... First, the poor state of the physical infrastructure, both in terms of quantity and quality. While with the healthy fundamentals of the domestic financial sector and the enhanced interest of foreign investors, funding should not pose a problem, issues relating to regulatory framework and rapid execution need to be addressed by the government.

Second, fiscal consolidation. The recent budget of the central government targets a gross fiscal deficit of 3% of GDP by 2009. This requires fiscal empowerment, which is possible through two routes (i) elimination of subsidies or (ii) elimination of tax exemptions. While in any economy fiscal consolidation is hard, it is particularly so in our setting

Third, India is set to remain one of the youngest countries in the world in the next few decades. This 'demographic dividend' cannot be used to the economy's advantage unless prerequisites such as skill-upgradation and sound governance to realise it are put in place.

Fourth, there is a need to shift the emphasis from foreign institutional investment to attracting foreign direct investment, which is less volatile. This requires a more favourable investment climate in general both for domestic and foreign capital.

Global Imbalances... As India does not depend on the international capital market for financing the fiscal deficit, the extent of adverse consequences of the global developments would be muted. However, there could be a spillover effect of global developments on domestic interest rates and thus on fiscal position. Also, a faster rise in rates overseas could lead to a shift in investor confidence to the international markets. Further, should there be a reversal of capital flows, asset prices may decline. With this there is a risk that rise in interest rates in general could impact the housing market and expose the balance sheet of the households to interest rate risk, increasing the risk of loan delinquencies for banks. Banks in India have invested significantly in government debt and other fixed income securities. If a rise in international rates gets reflected in domestic interest rates, banks will also have to mark down the value of their investment portfolio.

Multilateral confidence... Finally, there needs to be the confidence of the investor community on multilateral aspects such as political stability, terrorism combating ability and significance at global economic platforms (such as the IMF and World Bank).

While we do not intend to sound pessimistic about the continued resilience of the economy to global and internal shocks, investors investing in the India story should assess these grounds before judging the 'market risk' to be assigned to a stock. Weighing this with the premium expected to be earned over and above the risk free rate (10 year GSec yield), will help you correctly align your portfolio as per your risk profile.

Additional Readings:
  • India needs to reduce dependence on oil import: World Bank
  • FII currency play behind bounce
  • Midcaps braced to play the catch-up game next
  • Gujarat Ambuja: In changing times
  • Sensex at 12.3K again; blue chips still languish
  • How will ECS' decision on CBM impact RNRL?
  • Why is CLSA bullish on cement?
  • Sebi makes it easier for foreign investors
  • Investment tips to get higher-returns
  • Brokers bullish on Selan Exploration, Cipla
  • Racy Stocks - These companies are persistently growing their revenues for the last three quarters, have a record of robust profitability and strong recent price performance
Off-Topic Readings:
  • 2 Indians in Forbes' richest Americans list
  • The 400 richest Americans
  • An investment plan for winners
  • 5 WISE rules of investing
Parting Thought:
  • It's easier to create money than to spend it. - Warren Buffett

Posted by toughiee at 6:32 PM | Permalink | Comments | links to this post

Property Stocks: Land bank chimera

Since the start of 2006, companies with significant land banks have seen their stock prices soaring. The justification given is that the market value of the land these companies own is being factored into the price. A few of these companies do not have anything directly to do with the real estate business. For example, Bombay Dyeing. Old textile mills sitting on large amounts of land have seen their stock prices go up by astonishing amounts. Swan Mills saw its prices treble in the last 80 days to Rs 3,190. Since June-end, the rate of rise has been more moderate for genuine real estate companies like Unitech, but even so their stocks have done better than the broader market. It is worth noting that there are many companies that own lots of land. Infosys owns around 800 acres of land. State Bank of India (SBI) also owns a large amount of property, and so does ITC. A few years back analysts had come with a similar theory on the stock price of SBI being underpriced because it owned assets like property and flats in the posh areas of metropolitan India. Their market value should, therefore, be factored into the stock price, it was argued. That logic turned out to be specious because SBI may never put these properties on the market. Before going gung-ho about any company that has some land on its books, investors need to figure out whether the land will ever be put on the market. And even if the answer is yes, whether it is worth paying price-earnings multiples in the range of 200-500 - as is the case with companies like Unitech and Swan.
Aviation Sector's Unreal rally The market may be celebrating the fall of high-priced oil a bit too soon. In the aviation sector, most listed stocks have rebounded from their lows, when in fact falling oil prices may have only a small impact on margins in a scenario of hyper competition. With the domestic sector continuing to attract new players - Indigo Airlines was the latest to launch in August - the new entrants will have no option but to offer steep discounts to build marketshare. This will force the incumbents to continue cutting prices, effectively neutralising the benefits of lower oil prices. Between early 2005 and March, 2006, the total number of airline seats offered in the domestic market has risen 55%, forcing a fare war. But costs have risen faster, which makes any rerating of the sector impossible for now despite lower oil prices. A look at Jet Airways’ last quarter numbers shows why. Even though net revenues grew 25.6%, overall expenditures rose twice as fast at 53.7%. A large part of this was due to fuel (about a third), but the fastest growing cost is not fuel, but employee remuneration, which more than doubled (up 106.5%) due to a ramp-up of operations. The story is likely to be much the same in the rest of the aviation sector, thanks to the induction of new aircraft, investments in ground handling, and higher payments for aircraft rentals. Lease rentals grew at a zippy 70.7% for Jet, even as other operating expenses have risen to account for a quarter of total costs. There is thus a strong possibility that the fall in oil prices will be more than compensated by rising costs of personnel, aircraft lease rentals, and interest costs. Jet, for example, had to shelve its plans to make a $800 million GDR/FCCB issue due to unsettled market conditions, choosing instead to borrow more from domestic banks at higher rates. With more than Rs 2,000 crore stuck in the aborted deal to buy Air Sahara, it is little wonder Edelweiss Securities has a clear sell on Jet. Since mid-July, Deccan Aviation has gained nearly 40%, Jet 19% and SpiceJet 18%, beating the BSE Sensex hollow (15%). The rally in aviation stocks is a bit premature, if not totally unreal.

Posted by toughiee at 6:14 PM | Permalink | Comments | links to this post

Thursday, September 21, 2006

The devil is in derivative!

Yesterday, the financial world was jolted by news of a big hedge fund, which lost more than US$ 3.5 bn in a gas futures contract. While the news did not get as much media attention as the 1998 debacle of the LTCM hedge fund where it had Nobel Prize winners on its rolls, it nonetheless highlights the danger of dealing with financial instruments such as futures or more generally derivatives.
Mind you, these were not the only cases of misuse of such instruments and the subsequent nasty outcomes. Prominent debacles include the 1994 bankruptcy of Orange County, one of California's richest, due to investments in some ultra-sophisticated derivatives and the 1995 failure of the 200-year old Barings Bank as a result of unauthorized futures and options trading by a rogue employee. Besides, the fear of a lot more financial institutions losing their shirts owing to such leveraged positions continues to loom large.
Infact, this is what Warren Buffett, widely acknowledged as one of the shrewdest investors ever, had said about derivatives in Berkshire Hathaway's 2002 annual report.
"The derivatives genie is now well out of the bottle, and these instruments will almost certainly multiply in variety and number until some event makes their toxicity clear. [They] are financial weapons of mass destruction, carrying dangers that, while now latent, are potentially lethal."
And Buffett is not alone in deriding derivatives; a lot of other value investors share his views. One would now ask 'What is it that make these instruments so risky?' The answer lies in the fact that derivatives are financial instruments that have no intrinsic value but derive their value from something else. They are mainly utilised for hedging the risk of owning things that are subject to unexpected price fluctuations e.g. foreign currencies, food grains, commodities and even equities.
Let us take an example to clarify things further. Consider the case of Mr. Chandar. He is a farmer and is certain that he can harvest 20 tons of rice. Currently, rice is trading at Rs 5 per kg. At current price levels, he will earn Rs 100,000 that will cover his yearly expenses. But he knows that if there were a bumper crop of rice all over the state, he would be forced to sell his rice at as little as Rs 2 per kg. In that case, he would fall short to meet the expenses.
So Chandar goes to the local rice merchant, Thakur, and enters into an agreement that three months hence, he will sell his twenty tons of rice to him at the rate of Rs 5 per kg. Now, our Thakur is not a simpleton and knows that three months hence, all the farmers would be selling their produce, and the rates that would be then would be about 15% to 20% lower than what it is now. So, Thakur offers to buy the rice at the price of Rs 4.2 per kg.
At this, Chandar argues that it is equally likely that in event of a poor crop, the price of rice may be higher than what it is now. Thakur and Chandar finally agree to a price of Rs 5 per kg of rice for 20,000 kgs to be delivered at Thakur's shop after three months.
This is what we know as the most primitive kind of a derivative contract. Such contracts are called "Forwards" (or a Forward Contract) and is one of the simplest type of a derivative contract. In order to cater to a large number of Chandars and Thakurs and to make sure that both the parties honour their commitments, boards or exchanges have been set up across the world which oversee derivative contracts in virtually every commodity and financial security.
So far so good! So long as the purpose of such contracts is to hedge against a possible fall or rise in prices, derivatives can prove to be an extremely useful tool. However, if speculators board the bus to benefit from the discrepancy in prices, then we might have huge problems in our hands. Speculators have no other interest apart from making bucks by benefiting from the gyration in prices. They just hope that the seller is wrong temporarily so that they can sell the contract at a higher price to some other guy and profit from the same. It is when these bets go wrong, hedge funds like Amaranth or LTCM, which use ultra-leveraged money to invest in such kind of contracts, vanish without a trace thus eroding considerable amount of wealth in the process.
These short-term contracts go against the very grain of value investing, which is based on principles that 'existence of value in the absence of assets' and 'predicting short-term price movements' can both prove to be a risky proposition. No wonder, it does not find a place in the investing world of value investors. As long as the purpose is to hedge against price fluctuation of some underlying asset, then the use is justified but if it is used as a source to earn quick money, then we might be in for some nasty surprises.
In these turbulent times in the Indian market, a lot of investors might be tempted to use such instruments in view of the fear that since it has run up quite a bit in the recent past, a correction is long overdue. Hence, any further purchase of equity should be hedged against a possible fall in order to minimise the damage. There is little wrong in this approach except for the fact that if it is being used for quick money making then be prepared to watch your hard earned money go down the drain. Infact, given its inherent risks, try and avoid it altogether. Happy investing!
Additional Readings:
  • CMC: ‘International’ growth!
  • India needs to reduce dependence on oil import: World Bank
  • Crude below $ 60: Buy HPCL, IOC and BPCL
  • List of companies that FIIs are generous on
  • India shoves US to become FDI destination No.2
  • Mkts may see correction tomorrow: IDBI Capital Mkt
  • Mkts to see 10,500 before Dec-end: Jagdish Malkani
  • What are Absolute Capital Mgnt's top India picks?
  • Where's the value in this rising market?
  • Brokers bullish on Gateway Distriparks, Gujarat Gas, Cipla
  • Thai coup won't impact surrounding economies: Murphy
  • 'Hot money' has probably disappeared from EMs: Jetfin
Additional Reports:
  • Many faces of Investor emotions
  • Shipping - MS
  • Oil & Energy - MS - Crude Oil to rebound
Off-Topic Readings:
  • Rude shock: EPF rate may dip to 8%
  • Indians getting richer, more demanding
  • Films at your doorstep, courtesy Seventymm
  • 100% insurance = 60% settlement
Parting Thought:
  • There's very little money to be made recommending our strategy [buy-and-hold].Your broker would starve to death. Recommending something to be held for 30 years is a level of self-sacrifice you'll rarely see in a monastery, let alone a brokerage house. - Warren Buffett

Posted by toughiee at 10:13 PM | Permalink | Comments | links to this post

Search


Compilations

  • Warren Buffett
  • Charlie Munger
  • Rakesh Jhunjhunwala

Last posts

  • Site Moved!
  • The real reason why oil prices are rising
  • New Blog!
  • How to think like J.P. Morgan?
  • They're wrong about oil
  • Investment Nuggets by Benjamin Graham
  • ‘Returns dip as motion rises’
  • Hunt for The Bottom!
  • What happened to India story?
  • Who should you trust your money with?

Archives

  • November 2005
  • December 2005
  • January 2006
  • February 2006
  • March 2006
  • April 2006
  • May 2006
  • June 2006
  • July 2006
  • August 2006
  • September 2006
  • October 2006
  • November 2006
  • December 2006
  • January 2007
  • February 2007
  • March 2007
  • April 2007
  • May 2007
  • June 2007
  • July 2007
  • August 2007
  • September 2007
  • October 2007
  • November 2007
  • December 2007
  • January 2008
  • February 2008
  • March 2008
  • April 2008
  • May 2008
  • June 2008

About This Blog

  • Get on Mobile
  • Atom Feeds
  • Disclaimer
  • Email to Owner

Blog Directories

  • Stockblogs

Related Blogs

  • DeepWealth
  • Dardashti
  • Ridgewood Group
  • Trading Day by Day

Business Papers

  • Economic Times
  • Business Standard
  • Business Line
  • Financial Express
  • DNA Money

Business News

  • Capital Market
  • Equitymaster
  • India Infoline
  • Moneycontrol.com
  • Yahoo! India Finance
  • ICICIdirect

Results

  • India Earnings

Quotes & Stats

  • Asian Indices
  • All Indian Quotes
  • Indian ADRs
  • Indian GDRs
  • Arbitrage
  • Sector Classification
  • FII Trends
  • MF Trends
  • NSE Heat Map
  • Insider Trading
  • BC/RD
  • BM (Company)
  • BM (Date)
  • BSE Bulk Deals
  • NSE Bulk Deals
  • NSE Block Deals
  • US Indices
  • US Pre-Market
  • US After Hours
  • CBOE VIX
  • European Indices
  • Commodity/Currency
  • Nymex Light Crude Oil
  • Nymex Natural Gas
  • Nymex Gold
  • Nymex Silver
  • Nymex Copper
  • All In One

Equity Analysis

  • Kotak Street
  • Moneypore
  • Geojit
  • IDBI
  • Naviamarkets
  • ET Big Bucks
  • BS Smart Investor
  • FE Investor
  • BL Investment World

Screeners

  • Equitymaster
  • ICICIdirect

Research Reports

  • Moneycontrol

Technical Analysis

  • ICICIdirect
  • Yahoo! Finance

E-Books

  • Value Investing
  • Trading & Technicals
  • Gann
  • Elliott Wave
  • Risk Management
  • Derivatives

Misc. Links

  • BSE
  • NSE
  • SEBI
  • SEBI Edifar
  • Corp. Filings
  • WatchOutInvestors

Global Research

  • Morgan Stanley GEF
  • Hussman Funds

Interactive

  • Online Chat
Subscribe to this blog's feed
[What is this?]
Powered by Blogger